Why do New Yorkers call pizza pie? Or is that an East coast thing? Anyway, Lombardi's is the oldest pizza place in Manhattan, since 1905. It's located in SoHO. Note that the garlic as a topping is free, but you have to ask for it. I still like Grimaldi's/Patsy's better. The wait at Lombardi's is shorter. Their dressing for Caesar salad has an over-powering mustard flavor. Instead, I recommend the house salad and mushroom topping (variety of mushrooms used).
32 Spring St New York